clothianidin, is manufactured by German agrochemical company Bayer, though it’s actually banned in Germany. It’s also banned in France, Italy and Slovenia. Those countries fear that clothianidin, which is designed to be absorbed by plant tissue and released in pollen and nectar to kill pests, is also dangerous to pollen- and nectar-eating bees that are critical to some plants’ reproductive success.

In 2003, the EPA approved clothianidin for use in the United States. Since then it’s become widely used, with farmers purchasing $262 million worth of clothianidin last year. It’s used on used on sugar beets, canola, soy, sunflowers, wheat and corn, the last a pollen-rich crop planted more widely than any other in the U.S., and a dietary favorite of honeybees.

During this time, after several decades of gradual decline, honeybee colonies in the United States underwent widespread, massive collapses.

Up to one-third have now vanished, troubling farmers who rely on bees to fertilize some $15 billion worth of U.S. crops and citizens who simply like bees. Though colony collapse disorder likely has many causes — from mites to bacteria to fungus to the physiological stresses and epidemiological risks of industrial beekeeping — pesticides are a prime suspect, and the EPA’s leaked documents (pdf) are troubling.

The memo, obtained by Colorado beekeeper Tom Theobald and publicized by the Pesticide Action Network, was written in November by scientists from the EPA’s Environmental Fate and Effects Division, who are considering Bayer’s request to use clothianidin in cotton and mustard. They describe how a key Bayer safety study used by the EPA to justify its original clothianidin approvals, which were granted before the study was actually conducted, was sloppily designed and poorly run, making it a “supplemental” resource at best.

“Clothianidin’s major risk concern is to nontarget insects (that is, honey bees),” write the EFED researchers (pdf). “Exposure through contaminated pollen and nectar and potential toxic effects therefore remain an uncertainty for pollinators.”

Some beekeepers and activists have now asked the EPA to reverse its clothianidin approval. An EPA spokesperson told Grist’s Tom Philpott that clothianidin will again be on sale this spring.

According to the EPA’s website, the clothianidin review has been moved back to 2012.

Image: Flickr/Jack Wolf.

See Also:

• The Silent Spring of the Honeybees
• Mysterious Bee Disappearance Could Disrupt U.S. Agriculture
• Whatever Happened to Whatever Happened to the Bees?
• Bee Colony Collapse May Have Several Causes
• EPA Reverses Controversial ‘Human Guinea Pig’ Rule
• Human Pesticide Testing’s Greatest Hits

Brandon’s Twitter stream and reporter’s notebook; Wired Science on Twitter.

Authors: Brandon Keim

to know more click here